‘Safe working with mooring lines needs a turnaround in thinking’
Accidents caused by parting mooring lines are common in the shipping industry. Following the investigation into the fatal incident with a crew member of the RN Privodino, the Dutch Safety Board comes with several recommendations. Most notably, they advise a new way of working in which unsafe areas no longer need to be entered.
On 28 June 2018, the chemical tanker RN Privodino entered the Noordersluis lock at IJmuiden. The vessel was en route to Amsterdam. Shortly after the port forward spring had been paid out, it unexpectedly came under severe tension. The mooring team on the foredeck was no longer able to respond adequately in good time, as a result of which the mooring line parted. The section of mooring line that was connected to the on-board winch recoiled, and struck a crew member, killing him instantly.
Safety measures could not prevent accident
As mooring line accidents occur frequently, safety management measures have been developed and implemented to act as so called barriers. In the report, four failing barriers are identified which led to the fatal accident. These barriers are:
- Slowing down the vessel on time.
- Only place the spring under tension when the vessel reaches its final position in the lock.
- Intervention by mooring team leader (supervision).
- Working outside the Snap-back zones.
According to the Dutch Safety Board, analysing the failing barriers provides valuable starting points for measures to improve safety.
The Dutch Safety Board issues eight recommendations to various parties following this accident. With the aim of preventing the breaking of mooring lines in the lock in IJmuiden, to the Central Nautical Management North Sea Canal area:
1. After consulting with all stakeholders, formulate an ambitious target aimed at drastically reducing the number of broken mooring lines;
2. Take control in the redesign of the procedures relating to the precise determination and reaching of the final mooring position in the lock.
In respect of good cooperation on the bridge between regular members of the bridge team and the registered pilot, to SCF Management Services Dubai and the pilotage service:
3. Ensure that it is clear to all persons involved how the lock passage will be undertaken. Make a precise agreed and verified determination of the final position in the lock.
4. Ensure that whenever agreements are reached on board about the distribution of tasks during sailing and manoeuvres, these agreements are respected and that they do not conflict with the formal role and responsibility of the various persons involved according to their own discipline.
With regard to safe working with mooring lines on board, to SCF Management Services Dubai:
5. Ensure that during mooring line handling, crew members only undertake tasks after they have been issued with the appropriate instructions by a superior. Ensure that a start is only made on placing mooring lines under tension following the issuing of an instruction by the ship’s officer in command on the bridge.
6. Ensure that officers who are expected to physically supervise the safety of crew members are always able to give priority to this task.
Turnaround in thinking
The last two recommendations revolve around a turnaround in thinking when working with mooring lines. Whereas at present the intention is to ensure that measures for working safely in unsafe areas are carried out as well as possible, working with mooring lines and ropes must be organised in such a way that at high risk moments, it is possible to work from a safe location and unsafe areas no longer need to be entered.
To achieve that objective the Dutch Safety Board recommends to SCF Management Services Dubai:
7. In areas with snap-back zones, identify or create safe workstations where those aboard cannot be hit by mooring lines and ropes if they snap back; mark these safe workstations in a recognizable manner and organize the work processes involving mooring lines and ropes in such a way that operations are always undertaken from these safe workstations.
The Dutch Safety Board also calls on the Netherlands Maritime Technology (NMT) and the Royal Association of Netherlands Ship Owners (KVNR) to:
8. Broadcast this turnaround in thinking as widely as possible in their national and international network, and investigate how, in practical terms, the maritime sector can contribute to achieving the objective of only working from safe workstations while handling mooring lines.
Safer mooring lines
The Dutch Safety Board does not mention the use of mooring lines with no or reduced snap-back, such as the Snap Back Arrestor (SBA), developed by Wilhelmsen Ships Service. This type of rope has an energy absorbing core. If the outer, load-bearing construction breaks, the SBA absorbs the snap-back forces, transforming them from a potentially deadly snap, to a much safer, slump. This would also significantly reduce mooring line accidents. Shipping company Maersk began implementing this type of mooring line in June 2020.